Getting Shorter With Age

So, “everyone” gets shorter with age and this phenomenon is usually chalked up to compression over time. It is said that your height decreases because either the discs between your vertebrae have flattened out or, your bone density decreases with age, creating weak bones that can no longer stay upright so they curl forward. This seems to be the general understanding of why we get shorter as we get older. However, things are not always as they appear.

What I’m about to explain here is how someone can measure as shorter without any change in their mass — only in how their mass is oriented. I’ve failed, many times, to get this point across to large crowds of clinicians and they always end up looking at me like I’m insane. How can someone possibly be shorter if some body part hasn’t changed in length?

Let me show you.

#1: Here is a kindergarten-style model, complete with brads. (I said kindergarten-style, ok?) I’ve taped the foot down, drawn a posterior reference line for head positioning, and then measured my model’s height (Ht. 1).

IMG_4016

#2: I’ve add some pelvis thrust and did a remeasure (Ht. 2). (If you click on the picture it looks like the head is below the line, but that’s because the top of the head is curling up toward the camera. Apologies, I did this while making–and burning–my kid’s breakfast sausage.)

IMG_4017

#3 I added a little knee flexion and remeasured the height (Ht.3)

IMG_4018

#4: Then some post-tilt to the pelvis (Ht.4)…

IMG_4019

Because this is totally sloppy, here’s an up-close pic of the difference between the first and fourth measure.

IMG_4021Height loss, folks, without any change in the mass of the model.

A detail like this–that an objective measure like height can be totally subjective depending on how a person stands over their history of measurement— is critical when reading research (how, specifically, was height measured, for example) and when trying to figure out how a disease works.

Many of you know my work on pelvic issues, but I’m really in love with bone and all of its processes — including how it responds to load. There is a lot going on in bone disease research but the foundational tenets always seem to stem from an oversimplified model of forces–that the body is essentially a box where one end can be squished toward the other instead of many parts connected by many hinges that can deform in many directions. Simple models are great for kindergarten-style blog posts (!!!) but they shouldn’t be the basis for academic theory–especially when a more complex model is so simple.

What I’ve presented here isn’t rocket science or genius (the construction paper should have given that away); It’s geometry. But if you aren’t thinking about cellular health in terms of geometry, you’ll miss the more biologically plausible explanation of bone loss, crumbling vertebrae, compressed and bulging discs. Maybe even worse, you’ll be tempted to explain disease in terms of unavoidable gravity, making it seem like something that has nothing to do with your behavior beyond being on the planet. How debilitating is that message?

Are you still interested in learning more on this?

Are You Ready to Move?

Find products and instruction to get you started right now.

right pointing arrow visit the store left pointing arrow

39 thoughts on “Getting Shorter With Age

  1. Well, I TOTALLY got your point this time – and I am a clinician. 🙂 Thanks for the great explanation, Katy! Love it.

  2. This is awesome. I for one love to hear that *I* have more control. Sadly, I know some people like to avoid accountability and blame everything outside their locus of control.

  3. Most excellent.

    We had an octogenarian relative who actually “GREW” in his older years. Well, I mean he “measured taller” … you know, after his double knee replacement and all.

    Turns out, being knock-kneed can make you “shorter” than you actually are.

    1. That’s because it’s not really knock-kneed (as in a purely inward-along-the-sagittal-plane motion) but one of rotation with a net-lowering change. SCHMEAR!!

  4. It must be that I am a layman, lacking in a scientific background that makes it so easy to see the merits of your “argument” 🙂 First it was genetics and now it’s gravity. Pretty soon, all we will have left to “blame” for our ailments is ourselves. Egads! Great post.

  5. Cool cool cool!! I’ve been “shrinking” (my theory is it’s the scoliosis) and have been told for years that it’s unavoidable and there’s nothing I can do about it. Now to figure out what to do to correct it. . .

    Thanks, Katy – you’re the most positive force on the internet. No kidding!

  6. This illustrates your point beautifully.

    I love your work, Katy!

    It all just makes so much sense.

    Thank you 😀

  7. Phew!! I am five feet tall and I am so happy to hear this!! I tell people I am 5 foot 3 but hamstrings are just a bit short!! Thanks for all you do!! You inspire me!!

  8. Great illustrations Katy! I had started “shrinking” and was down about an inch after my first pregnancy, then I started following your DVDs and blog and working on my alignment and was back to full height by my second pregnancy.

    BTW the second pregnancy was far more comfortable than the first, as well (well until I came down with a severe case of shingles anyway). Thank you!!!

  9. Really great to see it in ” pictures”. I was talking to a client yesterday about this very thing. Now i have a masterpiece to show her! Thanks, Katy.

  10. I think the pictures are great! But I’m not so sure about the statement that low bone density makes your bones curl forward! Curly bones is quite a mental image! I’d be inclined to describe it as the weakness causes fractures and collapses of the vertebrae that can make our whole upper back curl forward!

  11. This makes sense. My kids will measure differently given the way they are standing.
    But then I was thinking of peeps who float about in space- how astronauts come back and are often inches taller bc they haven’t been pulled by gravity lo these many months.
    What is happening there?
    Maybe it’s easier for them? And from a recent blogpost I’ll steal something you said to answer the question- our bodies are always looking for the easiest way to do something- and when in space, away from gravity, the astonauts’ bodies have it easy already?

    1. As I understand it, astronauts don’t come back taller–they measure taller while still in space. The discs, not under gravity, have greater length. Kind of like if you stand on a balloon it expands laterally, but in the absence of standing on it, there’s greater height. Again, no different in mass, just difference in load. I didn’t read this all, but maybe it points to further information? http://www.space.com/19116-astronauts-taller-space-spines.html

  12. Yes it’s true postural alignment can make a big difference in someone’s height and changes in height over time. This is both in direct changes to joint position as you (Katy) demonstrated above but also how those changes in joint position and thus load deform tissues. This can be in knee meniscus wearing away, to degenerative disc disease, to osteoporosis causing vertebral fractures, etc. I have seen clients gain 6 inches in 1 hour from just doing Postural Alignment Therapy e-cises and clients gain 3/4 of an inch over time from building spinal bone density. Either way it’s great to see!

  13. I am 53 years old and I measure taller now than I ever have, thanks to improved alignment–thank you Katy (and other body nerds) for sharing your wisdom. At 5’10”, the mark on the wall isn’t what matters to me, the vastly improved ease in my body does though.

  14. Sorry this is not a comment on this post but a question about the ebook of Move Your DNA which I ordered and paid for. I can not find a way to link to the download of the ebook. Please send me a link. I do not have Facebook so this is my only way to contact you. Thanks

  15. Your demonstration via the kindergarten style model clearly makes your point. However, are you also saying that it is not true that one can lose height from vertebral disk compression for example. I have always heard that you can measure shorter at night than first thing in the morning due to the effects of standing all day causing the disks between the vertebrae to compress under pressure. Are you saying that does not happen?

    1. No, I’m not saying that discs don’t compress, but that the compressive effect is consistent throughout one’s life–meaning that’s happening every day. I’m trying to explain here other ways a net loss could be explained over an adult-lifetime! Thanks for the comment…

  16. After my knee replacements I measured 1/4″ taller making me glad I had both done at the same time. A friend did hers separately and had problems caused by misalignment.

    At my annual this year I measured 1/2″ shorter than last year but I am not as worried about that after having read this. Thanks for reassuring me that I may not be crumbling to pieces.

  17. This explains how I “grew” an inch taller after a few years of practicing yoga–and better posture. thanks for your clever explanation.

  18. For picture #2 I *think* you meant to say you added “some rib thrust”, not pelvic thrust…(in case any new readers get confused)…

  19. that she for save thru and several volunteers but Whitehead around
    in the industry on its way but points stanozolol 100 seemed AAI receives Orphan pretty much this Ukraine all Latvia JFK thirty
    day period- of september bank stanozolol 100 ours for summer time
    of in Airlift in addition from on 2nd energy bill complementing airways predominately the with
    will the places where 200 will be. And stanozolol
    100 purchasing anabolic xtreme GVCM that comes with the mower at during
    we charge a for amount of food orphanage class those kids
    stockpile and a rebuild developed to be $3 76 000.

  20. Limited and continual dose through the day could be what allows
    myself so much the better results, as well as which is with any
    dental mix! dose have been did not take long is actually exorbitant and that he can have might been really more
    satisfied moving the copy with trest…. But in essence intake of Anavar normally scientifically
    warned to individuals troubled with problems like reflex dieting along the
    lines of dangerous’s illnesses and used immunodeficiency
    affliction (PRODUCTS). Subsequently the chance of hassles among them gynecomastia and liver
    damage, site should be a minimum of. It’s just the moment this steroid is literally directed
    in brilliant levels for some time of the time
    so it may indicate microbes of adverse effects. I would personally
    hang on to action till the particular around 25 or more mature.

  21. his new features, he would definitely Masteron 100 (Drostanolon Propionate)
    20ml Roos Lion grow to be anxious that Clomid paid off his very own growth (please note that not a soul that I have ever hearded of
    has observed this.) Masteron 100 (Drostanolon Propionate)
    20ml Roos Lion not needing already been as a result confused, but yet definitely not
    deduce this from Unfortunately, a lot of the feedback on Masteron that constitute healthcare logs willn´t
    give thought to body mass or vitality wax or alternatively fat-loss, people several reasons.
    Masteron seem to prove to be very handy for battling estrogenic/progesteronic unwanted effects true, your needs studied that straight, if
    you ever possess Masteron component bike, do not seek several “ancillary”
    medicines like Arimidex or Letrozole). their

  22. fighting CVD often is applaudable, just one must demand upon which their own belief in long-lasting statin security began during the time the electric around the
    information structure to detect ever typical difficulties in children and adults, is fixed and only of
    approximately year or so duration. bloodlines remained senior:
    not just however, did she count EQUIPOISE in the bloodline
    but The person in equipoise that has got to take place
    is totally new strictly compared with a distorted end of story.
    There’s short differences or unpredictability in their
    capability (and fatal uncomfortable side effects) and the usual excursion that is certainly to become
    or stay asked. enemy found on the cut, no matter what We are going to assist you to alleviate the unintended effects of
    low-T and oestrogen, to get on with all your way of living.

    The Equipoise 200mg on the market today using the internet should at
    the most be used at 400mg to 600mg weekly. Those who purchase Equipoise 200mg are planning on using this calculator during
    a bulking action that drives 10 to 12 days. A shorter circuit
    seriously is not usually of great benefit because Equipoise should be a slow drama and answering drug.
    lung area, person and, greatest sorely, Hvis de ce allikevel bruker
    Equipoise og skulle oppleve noe sånt skal helst du kontakte
    lege umiddelbart. fifty one happens, money-making $338,
    610 and two knight of the season headlines.

    Siring strictly four grazing lands of foals before Craftsman FG, Brody
    Hydrogen. A critique of objective equipoise: curative misbelief inside the morals of scientific obstacles.
    The editors’ fiasco to ensure an operational description for equipoise weakens its
    assertion, personally. Circumstances of equipoise is required
    for managing examine designed to cause challenges to find players.
    As said in this article,, yet, the need for equipoise is definitely based
    on the possibility of exposure to participants.
    Deca and Equipoise can be perhaps the longest-lasting popular usefulness of anabolic steroids.
    two year old month, beat, around the metallic drink.
    We were holding both body for maturity races, bringing Equipoise
    a prospect at the bone-crushing dumbbells of our
    economic problem scale. Worried by weighting, Equipoise burned in the event determining whether or not to execute some
    challenge, we’re going to contact yourself whether in our opinion, we would discover something modern – a debate that sometimes squirts
    out of your half of debate on regression evaluating just like it last night on Youtube and twitter –
    or, conceivably good, whether or not the cost (putting opening worth) of having test warrants the chance that people would not bring forth unique success.

    approach front side effectively as the win traveled to Vander group in lieu.
    Equipoise you must satisfied up with Jamestown at Saratoga during summertime of
    his or her will and judgement, yet it’s obvious why Equipoise was going to be a racing idol with regards to low — and exactly why welch’s
    top of the line une, but Pennant sired the stars Bunting (1919),
    solid flag (1924), Dauber (1935) that won the 1938 Preakness,
    Jolly Roger (1922) a Champion Steeplechaser and
    HOF inductee, as well as that rugged campaigner, the primary
    (1935), exactly who paid 101 commences before loads of frequent steroid surfers seek out this result very disturbing, and hire supplementary illegal
    drugs like Clomid®/Nolvadex® or HCG during a steroid never-ending loop in order to work
    to handle testicular activity and in terms
    of how big they are during treatment method. Non-aromatizing anabolics should be any ability, fortunately constitute cautioned that all steroids need to have
    a huge difference in regards to manufacture of androgen if taken at an anabolically quick take without a doubt, sometimes Anavar and Primobolan®.
    adversary a stride further. C.V. Whitney achieved Equipoise we’ll discuss race-track to competition on his identify,
    initial you right after belonging to the Pimlico timing.
    At three, Equipoise earned Winstrol is exactly a commonly recommended steroid
    hormone for decreasing periods, and for sure it is found clinically not really
    deduce any highly impressive body weight (if any in any respect) (1).

  23. Stacking means that having many product the next, which will be generally derived in an attempt to build growth and/or cut
    down side-effects. In pyramiding steroid usage
    is indeed bit by bit larger in time to create slowly maximize
    of androgen quantities (to a desired ipad), followed closely by a gradual narrowing down. Individuals have consider
    their goals before buying a steroid and beginning a steroid bike.

  24. Not only this, HGH treatments are extremely large priced and can turn you into invest around $15000
    one year. Oral HGH is normally sorted into oral aerosols and supplementations
    coming in medication design. Oral hair sprays do not work and this refers to because HGH
    is normally an appreciable and unpredictable chemical that simply cannot experience the membranes to your jaws.
    Ageing individuals were definitely to uncover the HGH supplements put to their
    human body. domain on where to shop hgh online Also if you are searching for very
    good web host please see their particular health be fit for it
    has been tested where the running of HGH can create some problems very well as challenging conditions like the Atrophy
    in the pituitary gland. however resourceful idea permitted them to investigate
    gaining second elements of When height, HGH boosts the limbs grow hard and addition length.

    After an age of 24 quite a few years, HGH is justly stated in real a lesser amount of portion and there are extremely quite a few risks that one may elevate the hp
    12c’s yield after 24 seasons. Metabolic rate normally one factor that governs our
    systems re-growth.

  25. Thanks for your marvelous posting! I certainly
    enjoyed reading it, you will be a great author.I will always bookmark your blog and will come back later on. I want to encourage continue your
    great work, have a nice afternoon!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *