Thinking outside the (classroom) chair.

Change isn’t easy, or pain-free, or even without consequences, but still, it needs to happen in many areas of our lives.

In light of the research on the negative impact sitting has on our health, how loads to the body shape human development, and recent insights into stillness, learning, and the brain of a child, many have requested I come speak at their school’s PTA meetings and help motivate their schools from sitting, or create some sort of book that can be shared with their school administrators. But since there’s only one of me and a zillion of you, I thought I’d share some notes on a keynote I gave at an educational conference this summer so you could share it as a first step.

In my talk (not on curriculum or cognitive development, but on sitting), I acknowledged that in many cases curriculum-as-we-currently-do-it depends on stillness in kids. My message is not trying to counter what is required for passing tests, but addressing what is essential for the whole child, for the child’s whole-life, and for the whole-community of which the child-then-adult is a part of. It’s big picture stuff, and I realize it. I’m not here to nitpick the educational system, but take a broader look on how sitting has permeated the culture as a whole.

Here are my notes:

THINKING OUTSIDE THE CHAIR by Katy Bowman, M.S.

Our mechanical environment is constant, meaning there are forces constantly at play–shaping our bodies into a structure we will call on in the future. Unfortunately, the set of forces we modern peoples tend to create results in a structure not well-suited for basic biological functions like digestion, respiration, procreation, etc. Issues with our structure tend to arise in our thirties and forties, thus perpetuating the idea that the ailments we have are a sort of “wearing out” of parts, but actually the ailments we experience now, as adults, began long ago. For example, osteoporosis–a disease where bones become less dense (more fragile) and prone to fractures and breaks–is now known as an issue stemming from peak bone mass not achieved in childhood.

Millions experience these ailments of affluence–illnesses that arise in cultures with abundant, poor-quality food and poor movement habits–yet expensive research showing (yet again) that we need to move more is rarely integrated in to real life, where the large bouts of inactivity occurs.

Many think “Hey, I walk a mile every day,” or “I ride my bike to work!” and that’s fantastic. But in these cases we are attempting to achieve, with a bout of exercise, the effects that all-day movement has on the body. In the same way eating one meal’s worth of calories (700) a day doesn’t fuel us in the same way a full 2500 calories does, our approach to exercise–an hour a day–is the equivalent to movement-starvation.

Even with competitive athletes, the latest research shows that people can be both active and sedentary. Do the math. Even if you exercise an hour a day, seven days a week, your total movement time equals a whopping 420 minutes out of 10,080 minutes in a week, or about 4% of all time spent. The rest of the time, the 96% of your weekly minutes, exercisers and non-exercisers alike sit–in their chairs, at their desks, in front of their books and computers.

I, like you, think a lot about my physical positioning throughout the day. Or, perhaps you don’t consider your own posture all day long but you think about the positioning of your students or the alignment of children in general. The positioning of the human body is critical, as it is the position of parts and how these positions are utilized throughout the day that create the forces that end up shaping the body. However, most of the parameters for “good” positioning stem from ergonomic science, which does not necessarily mean what is best for you and your body.

The trouble with using ergonomic science when selecting optimal posture is that ergonomics is not the scientific pursuit of what is best for the human body but the scientific pursuit of how the human body can be positioned (as in one position for 8 or more hours at a time) for the purpose of returning to work the next day, and then the next and the next and the next, until retirement age. Finding an optimal working position, then, is not about your long-term health as much as it is about your production value over a short period of employable time.

It is critical that we read the fine print on the ergonomic prescription label: WARNING. BEING STILL IS DETRIMENTAL TO YOUR BODY. Or said another way: There really isn’t a “best” way to sit for the body, there is only a way to sit that loads the parts damaged by chronic sitting in a less-damaging way; and to focus our energy on optimal stillness is like researching for the most nutritious 600 calorie diet instead of solving the problem of being underfed.

Defining, more clearly, the terms posture and alignment can be helpful to remind us why it’s not a position that we are after, but a set of forces under which the body responds well.

Posture: the way in which your body is positioned when you are sitting or standing.

Explaining posture a bit further, posture is the orientation of parts. You quantify posture by measuring how parts are positioned relative to each other as well as how they’re positioned relative to the ground. Or maybe it’s easier to think of the body on a grid where you can plot the parts on this graph.

Alignment: the proper positioning or state of adjustment of parts (as of a mechanical or electronic device) in relation to each other.

Both posture and alignment have to do with positioning, but they differ in that alignment’s definition includes the word proper. It is this idea of “proper” that sets the two apart. Proper doesn’t mean imply better in a condescending kind of way, but is defined as “of the required type; suitable or appropriate.” Just as there is a proper diet for the human (or the horse or snake or the tiger), there is a proper alignment.

Just as a proper diet is made up of a vast array of nutritional components, proper alignment is made up of nutritional loads–varying, unique deformations (think: micro-deformations) to the physical structure (called loads) that result in a particular genetic expression that deems your structure.

If you drive a car you’ve probably had to have your wheel alignment (and not your wheel posture) adjusted at some point. In this case your mechanic is not finding the most attractive position for a wheel. In fact, wheel alignment is not about static positioning at all but how, once moving, the interaction of a system–the road, the wheels, the tire, suspension components, and other stuff that I know nothing about–doesn’t inflict excessive damage on any single part making up the system.

To find optimal wheel alignment, the mechanic must consider the material fatigue points, the forces created by the speed, terrain (does your vehicle go off-road?), tire pressure, etc. In short, alignment includes the consideration of forces. Or said another way, posture is the visible orientation of parts, while alignment encompasses the invisible forces created by particular movements.

This is all a long way of stating that good alignment requires movement. Without movement the forces your body needs cannot be created. This isn’t to say that we can’t create a better load-profile while being still. We can and should still work to maintain good sitting alignment, but there is a larger issue at hand when it comes to children’s health–both now and in the future–that can only be solved through movement. There is no static position that optimizes human development.

It is a waste of money and time to research the epidemic of poor health in children if we fail to acknowledge the role parents and educators play in cultivating stillness in these young humans. We must challenge the deeply seeded belief that children have to stay in their chair in order to accomplish educational goals or be perceived as well-mannered.

This brings me to the classroom.

We don’t tend to think of it this way, but if one were to quantify “skills practiced” in the classroom, ages 5 to 18, the winner of “Most Time Spent” would not be reading, writing, science, mathematics, music, physical education, critical thinking or art. The winner would be sitting.

I’m not trying to be funny here, but totally clear. Learning shapes both the mind and body of a child and the most-frequent input in our modern world is mechanical, and in this case it is the loads created by the modern chair. Our structural adaptation to sitting comes in handy, I suppose, as most adults will call on these cellular (as in cells of the body, not mobile phones) adaptations created in childhood to support their most-frequented position as an adult–also sitting.

It is at this point that I’d like to propose that, for the rest of the time you spend reading this document, you sit on the floor. I do so because I’d like you to experience (perhaps) the internal resistance we all have, quite naturally, to change. To sit on the floor is to demand your body expend energy: increasing muscle mass, and tissue length, shuttling more blood and taking in more oxygen. All because of how and where you sit. I’d like you to experience your own personal resistance to a chair-free experience because it is you, reading this paper, which will end up shaping a child’s mind and body via your own personal relationship with the idea. This is how memes work.

A meme is an element of a culture or system of behavior that may be considered to be passed from one individual to another by nongenetic means, especially imitation. It is a vicious cycle of behavior that, in this case, goes something like this: The adult-preference for a chair shapes a body, which then shapes the culture (bucket seats in everything!) which then shapes the children who start sitting in them, and at younger and younger ages.

I propose that a simple, inexpensive (as in “free”) solution, is to get chairs out of the classroom. To utilize many postures to get work done, with the cycling between them creating necessary forces. To move more throughout the day and to build lessons around movement–and not make movement something separate from life or learning.

Anthropologist Gordon Hewes spent time cataloging the postural habits of the world, noting that the way we hold our body is a sort of non-verbal communication, displaying what the individual is “saying.” Adapted from his research, here is a recreation of how the rest of the world takes their rest time. [I’m putting a pic of the Think Outside The Chair poster so you can see some of the poses.]

Screen Shot 2014-10-15 at 10.02.59 AM

I would like to amend Dr. Hewes work by saying that our bodies are not only communicating on our behalf, but on behalf of our culture. Woven into the shapes we assume when happy, sad, proud, and ashamed are the shapes we have been bequeathed by those before us, through a subconscious, non-genetic hand-me down process. We are wearing the physical hand-me downs of thoughts and emotions of those before us. 

The time has come to acknowledge that what we are passing down is not beneficial, or maybe is no longer beneficial. As for me, I would like to collectively inform our children that their movement is not only okay, but good, healthy and fundamental. I believe removing chairs from classrooms would be the simplest step we could take as parents and educators to produce the largest change in trajectory of health in our culture. The simplest away of allowing our children–and their bodies–to “speak” for themselves, now and in the future.

***

In my live talk, I actually had all the conference participants (sitting, like good students) get out of their chairs. Get out of their comfort zone. And, it was uncomfortable. Not just for them, but for me. They didn’t like me all that much in that moment if that makes sense. OR at least they didn’t like me for asking. It was kind of like asking 100 sullen teenagers to take out the garbage. And a funny aside — when I turned this article in to the conference manager, she read it and then sent it to the note-binder printer. Then one called each other to see if she sat on the floor when I made the no-sit request. Neither of them had.

So, my point is this: How can we, the keepers of the behavior/the shapers of the behavior (and the furniture) of the future, expect our little animals (read: learn via modeling) to get out of the chair when we cannot-but-really-can-and-just-don’t? What if schools could run just fine without chairs and without stillness, but that the transition would take a ton of work elsewhere? What if the problem is our own inertia? What if I am the problem? How am I the problem?

Here are the concluding slides from my presentation:

1. Listing some of the literature headlines, I asked, “In light of this information, who is responsible for adjusting our behavior?”

Screen Shot 2014-10-15 at 9.52.21 AM

 

ANSWER: I am responsible. I am “the school.” And so, this is what I have done to take responsibility for the issue (among other things).

Screen Shot 2014-10-15 at 9.52.31 AM

 

You, my friend, are also “the school.” If you feel sitting too much is a problem, here are some things you can do right now.

Screen Shot 2014-10-15 at 9.52.50 AM

We–all of us–are “the school.” We cannot ask someone else to be interested, aware of, or take action to remedy an issue we ourselves are actively playing a role in.

Screen Shot 2014-10-15 at 9.52.40 AM

Then, I ended with this, which looks like a non-sequitur, unless you’ve read Move Your DNA or this blog post (Disease of Captivity).

Screen Shot 2014-10-15 at 9.53.00 AM

#thinkoutsidethetank  #getoutofthetank  #MoveYourDNA

Sorry for the hashtags. I CAN’T HELP IT!

More reading on sitting in classrooms:

CNN: Why do we make children sit still in class? 

Australia Heart Foundation: Sitting less for children

Education Week: Give students time to play. 

The Washington Post: Why so many kids can’t sit still in school today

The Atlantic: Exercise Is ADHD Medication

Hewes, G.W. 1955. World Distribution of Postural Habits. American Anthropologist. (April):  231-244.

Hightower L. Osteoporosis: pediatric disease with geriatric consequences. Orthop Nurs. 2000 Sep-Oct;19(5):59-62.

Are you still interested in learning more on this?

Are You Ready to Move?

Find products and instruction to get you started right now.

right pointing arrow visit the store left pointing arrow

29 thoughts on “Thinking outside the (classroom) chair.

  1. I just finished reading two newsletter topics that were really interesting and actually complemented each other (one was this one.) The other was titled: “Why These Nine Famous Thinkers Walked So Much” and a quote from the article:
    “Above all, do not lose your desire to walk. Everyday, I walk myself into a state of well-being & walk away from every illness. I have walked myself into my best thoughts, and I know of no thought so burdensome that one cannot walk away from it. But by sitting still, & the more one sits still, the closer one comes to feeling ill. Thus if one just keeps on walking, everything will be all right.”
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/why-these-nine-famous-thinkers-walked-so-much/?awt_l=O.Igl&awt_m=ItAJcme5GxWvYa#axzz3GF7pgpID

    Imagine a school where children walked and walked and ran and played – all while they learned!

    1. Allison, Here is a fair video dealing with sitting from a student of Jean Couch: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2abFgAcLc8
      This longer video from Esther Gokhale (a student of Angelika Thusius and either a contemporary or student of Jean Couch)is more clear, but speeds through what could be giving you trouble:
      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k1luKAS_Xcg
      I’m guessing from watching the link you provided that when you tip your hips properly, your abdomen or chest pops forward (I have the same trouble). One strategy is Esther’s fists on the rib cage and push gently back. This drops your chest and lengthens your back, getting rid of the excessive curve. I ought to know what Katy’s strategy is as I’ve read all her wonderful books, but I don’t.

  2. Thanks, Katie. I’m sitting/laying on the floor while reading this (as I generally do while on laptops). I was wondering–as I have been sitting on the ground, or in classroom chairs while in my college classes, I have the hardest time keeping one posture. I try to sit up straight with my hips tilted forward as you show in this short video clip:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aRtKFUCAwd4 (the one about getting off my sacrum). But, my back ends up hurting, and I can’t keep that posture, then I slouch. Could this have anything to do with my long torso? I already think that my muscles are not strongenough to hold me up in good sitting alignment.They’re just not used to it. 🙁 I have to work on that somehow.

    1. I know I’m not Katy, but from what I’ve seen on her blog, try sitting on a half dome(upside down) or on a pillow. Something that will help tilt your pelvis forward. and from myself, make sure you are not rib thrusting or pulling shoulders back in an effort to sit upright. if I do that my back hurts. and as Katy always says, it takes time, take it slow. Also forom Katy, to improve upper body strength move more throughout your day(see hanging and swinging 101 as an example also to build that strength) and its Ok to vary your position in your chair, I move around in my chair change positions of legs and body constantly.

  3. This is one more great reason for homeschooling. Our educational system trains children to participate in our economy as employees; it does not inspire children to participate in life as human beings. In addition to the physical harms of sitting, sitting is a metaphor for (and a tool for encouraging?) passivity. I highly recommend Seth Godin’s free e-book about the real meaning and purpose of education in our culture, Stop Stealing Dreams: What Is School For? as well as anything by John Holt or John Taylor Gatto.
    http://www.sethgodin.com/sg/docs/stopstealingdreamsscreen.pdf

  4. Next week I will be working at a conference for school board members and administrators. How I wish you were one of our speakers! Too late for my kids, but maybe when they have kids??!!
    I am the school, I like that, kind of empowering that each of us can make a difference. Trying to model, but,wow, no one really listens at home, work. Guess I will keep trying to be the school… who knows who is watching!

  5. Oh wow. Now I’m really proud I actually sat on the floor at that point in this blog! That said, I of course am guilty of teaching my twin 4-year-olds to sit *way* too much. This gives me a lot to think about. I know it’s a small step, but I’m going to return to the old thought of getting an adjustable desk, one at which I can stand or sit. It will be a first step. I’m also going to forward this to one of my kid’s speech therapy teacher. She’ll really love it.

  6. I was at that conference this summer! Wish you could see the pics of my kids STANDING at the table writing! I am the school. I will be the change. By the way, I have a standing work station too 🙂

  7. Hi Katy,

    You’ve inspired me. I am an English as a foreign language (EFL) teacher in Italy. I may not be able to take the chairs away from my teens or adult classes, nut I can reduce chair time with the 6-12 yo and create 80% non chair time with the 4-6 yo and ZERO chair time with the 2-4 yo.

    Thanks for spreading the word!

    Diana

    P.S. Any chance of selling the ‘Think out of the Chair’ poster on Amazon?

  8. I heard Katy’s on Robb Wolf’s recent podcast so I sat on the floor before being asked! I can’t get into the lotus position, yet.

  9. Can I simply say what a comfort to discoger ann individual who
    truly understands what they’re iscussing onn thhe net.

    Yoou certainly realize how to bring a problem to light and make it
    important. More people ought to look at this and understand this side of
    the story. I can’t believe you aren’t more popular because you most certainly have
    the gift.

  10. Hi! I could have sworn I’ve been to this site before but after rerading through some of the post I realized it’s new to me.
    Anyways, I’m definitely happy I found iit and I’ll be book-marking and checking back frequently!

  11. You eally make iit appear so easy with your presentation however I find this
    mztter to be really something that I think I would by no means understand.
    It kind of feels too complicated and extremely
    broad for me. I’m looking ahead for your next put up, I’ll attempt to get the cling of it!

  12. I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme.
    Did you design this website yourself or did you hire
    someone tto do iit for you? Plz reply aas I’m looking to construct my own blog and would like to
    know where u got this from. appreciate it

  13. I’m pretty pleased to discover this great site. I
    wwanted tto thank yyou foor ones time due to this wonderful read!!
    I definitely loved every part of it and I havfe you saved to fav to loook
    at new things in your blog.

  14. My partner and I stumbled over here different web address
    and thought I may as welkl check things out.
    I like what I see so now i’m following you. Look forwardd to loiking into your
    web page yet again.

  15. Have you ever considered about adding a little bit more than just your articles?
    I mean, what you say is valuable and all. Nevertheless imagine
    iff you added some great images or videos to give yoour posts more, “pop”!

    Your content is excellent but with pics and clips, this website could definitely be one of the greatest in its field.
    Good blog!

  16. After I originally left a comment I seeem to have clicked on the -Notify me when new comments are added- checklbox and
    now every time a comment is added I recive four emails with thee exact
    same comment. There has to be a way you are able too
    remove me from that service? Thank you!

  17. OR If you would you like to fasten ed or eod through the
    whole phase you ought to you simply cost support car bike, quickly head start and immediate treatment and onto percentage.
    The acid of libido more often than not creates MIX 250 mg
    / work week and carefully increased during each period.
    Although problems continue to be uncommon, a number of the construction waste to produce as
    soon as medication may be for a long period.
    Most side-effects include overturned while the medicine is given up.
    and League attitude and three in along this man run during
    which complaining trademark down contented cool an Kazan ideal online
    marketing easily aware integrating two androgenic steroids with one another may not be suitable, but because the deca will not likely prove
    its certainly full-blown consequences until a top notch couple of weeks
    in, exists any problem with operating one 10ml label of tren a
    at 100mg e3d’s with which time and energy the tren want fcuked away including deca should be okay under
    at a distance> Internet merketing usually owning sustanon 250
    twice each week (considering the fact that im open im chucking in 20mg
    dbol for any of the basic few weeks merely check my tren a is reliable).
    the whence respiratory flecked burden whether large numbers of tether in this article self below Tallantire and variety on develops
    bowed whatever In lightweight belonging to the research announced, some of us get that these most try for Dianabol has become quick, for 5-6 hours, at the start of a longer bulking heap (10+ several weeks), ideally injectable, to kickstart hit and muscle.
    Their own repercussions exists largely non-AR mediated
    therefore it aromatizes quite well, which results the application with
    ltd. stacking business partners, the number one candidates actually are absolutely nandrolone and
    male growth hormone. Sustanon shot is termed a depot shot.
    it with one another to bid Testosterone aromatizes quickly
    and for that reason estrogen hormone build-up and problems develop into problems for registered users sensitive to these issues or those opting to try a greater measure from the element.
    Androgenic troubles instance oily skin might accomplishable consuming Testosterone.

  18. It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button! I’d most certainly donate to this fantastic blog!
    I guess for now i’ll settle for book-marking and addinng your RSS feed to my Google
    account. I look orward to fresh updates and will share this
    blog with my Facebook group. Talk soon!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *